A U.S. map shows the most uniquely popular Thanksgiving pies by state in 2024. Cream is the most uniquely popular in nine states. Pumpkin is most popular in seven western states. French silk pie is popular in seven Midwestern states. Five states make sweet potato pie popular. Other pie flavors include strawberry rhubarb, peanut butter and coconut custard. 11 states are categorized with "other" pie types.