This graphic demonstrates how much you can expect to pay for various factors that insurance providers measure when you have an insurance policy in Syracuse, NY. If you have a clean record, the insurance provider that will be the cheapest for you is GEICO at $137 per month, and the provider that is the most expensive is Liberty Mutual at $332 per month. For those that have an accident on their record, the cheapest provider and the most costly will be Liberty Mutual ($332) and GEICO ($150) respectively. If you’ve gotten a speeding ticket, Liberty Mutual and GEICO will be the most affordable and the least affordable, at $674 and $137. Finally, for those that have had a DUI, the least expensive provider is GEICO at $137, and the most costly is Allstate at $363.