Profitability = average combined ratio for 2019-23 period, weighted by annual GWP
Volatility = weighted standard deviation of annual combined ratios reported for 2019-23 period

Criteria for inclusion: 5 years of trading, with more than £100mn of GWP in at least 3 of those years
Also excluded: life syndicates, RITC syndicates and SPAs

* Syndicates which changed ownership/management during the period