McAllen, TX Auto Insurance Rates by Company vs. City Average

This is a graphic that takes the top insurance providers in McAllen, TX and compares their average monthly rates of insurance against the city average of $389. The state's top providers and the percent difference between their average cost and the average cost in the city are: Allstate (26%), American Family (26%), GEICO (-26%), Nationwide (24%), Progressive (7%), State Farm (-41%), and USAA (-47%).