This graphic takes the top insurance providers in Tallahassee, FL and compares the average monthly cost of their respective premiums against the average cost of $328. The state’s top providers, and the percent difference that is between their average monthly cost and the average cost in the city as a whole are: Allstate (42%), GEICO (-7%), Liberty Mutual (3%), Nationwide (-9%), Progressive (18%), State Farm (-28%), and USAA (-42%).