Provision Subject Particulars in Contention Grounds of Challenge
Clause 12, 51Risk Behaviour; At risk for HIV InfectionIt categorises transgender persons, men having sex with men, and female sex workers as 'at risk' for HIV/AIDSViolates Article 14:
a) Deprives transgender persons, gay and bisexual men, and female sex workers the right to donate blood based on gender identity and sexual orientation.
b) No correlation between goal to make blood donation safe, and the exclusion of said group of persons.
c) Basis for exclusion is negative stereotypes in society against this group of persons.
Violates Article 15:
a) Only factor for categorising them into 'at risk' factor was sexual orientation and gender identity.
Violates Article 21:
a) the exclusion perpetrates the idea that such persons are not worthy of participating in society.
b) further marginalisation of transgender persons and persons of different sexual orientation worsens their status in society